All Posts

Reclaiming the Promise of Arbitration

By Phil Cutler[1]

From the earliest days of the Washington Territory, arbitration has been a recognized method of dispute resolution in our state;[2] the Legislature enacted Washington’s first arbitration act in 1869.[3] Historically, arbitration has been popular, especially among businesses; notwithstanding its higher forum costs (the parties pay not insignificant filing fees and bear the cost of compensating the arbitrator), it offered parties a number of benefits not available in a litigation forum:  the opportunity to select the decision-maker, usually someone experienced in resolving business disputes; confidentiality; an early opportunity for a hearing on the merits; and a final award, not subject to interminable appeals.  Moreover, arbitration was a more expeditious and less expensive alternative to litigation, largely because “discovery” and motions practice in arbitration were limited and parties had no need for significant case preparation time.

Continue reading

Practice Pointers for the Lawyer Advising Clients in Mediation-A Mediator’s Perspective

Just as mediation is an art, not a science, there is an art to advocacy in mediation.  I have developed the following “pointers” during the course of over 30 years as a trial lawyer in complex commercial and business disputes, and 25-plus years serving as mediator in such cases.  Although they reflect my personal experience as lawyer and mediator in commercial cases, the essential learning points cut across practice lines.

Continue reading

Suggested Format for an Agreed Mediation Plan Under the King County Superior Court Early Mediation Pilot Project

Below is my suggested format for an agreed mediation plan to be filed in those King County cases slected for the Early Mediation Pilot Program. A Word version is available here: Agreed Mediation Plan ****************************** SUPERIOR COURT OF WASHINGTON FOR KING COUNTY CAPTION AGREED MEDIATION PLAN COME NOW the parties to this case, by and through their attorneys of record,…

Continue reading

King County Superior Court Early Mediation Pilot Project

Historically, only 3-5% of civil cases filed in King County Superior Court proceed to trial. Some are disposed of on motion, some plaintiffs simply withdraw their complaint; most are resolved by settlement – often through mediation. While mediation offers a proven and effective means of resolving a dispute prior to trial, the later it occurs in the “life” of a…

Continue reading

Could Your Cases Profit from Early Neutral Evaluation

Most of us are familiar with the typical forms of alternative dispute resolution (ADR), mediation and arbitration, but how many of us are familiar with a relatively new form of ADR called Early Neutral Evaluation (aka Neutral Evaluation)? Early Neutral Evaluation (ENE), for certain types of cases, or at certain points in a case, can be more beneficial to a…

Continue reading

Book Review: Business and Commercial Litigation in Federal Courts, 2nd Edition

An edited version of the below article was published in the King County Bar Bulletin in December 2006. Below article © Phil Cutler 2006; published version © King County Bar Association 2006. Book Review: BUSINESS AND COMMERCIAL LITIGATION IN FEDERAL COURTS, SECOND EDITION (Robert L. Haig, Editor-in-Chief) Published by ABA Section of Litigation and Thomson/West, 2005 Review by Phil Cutler…

Continue reading

Sample Pre-Hearing Order #1

USAGE NOTE: The below represents the general form and content of the order I normally enter in AAA-administered arbitrations – where I am the sole arbitrator – following the initial preliminary hearing with the parties/counsel. It should be read in conjunction with the agenda letter and agenda I send out prior to the initial preliminary hearing. I use a substantially…

Continue reading

Memo to Client Re: Mediation

WHAT IS MEDIATION? Mediation is a process. The mediator attempts to facilitate an out-of-court settlement between the parties by building upon areas of common agreement and by challenging the parties and their lawyers to think critically about the case, potential outcomes, and the business and other risks which attend continued pursuit of the lawsuit. WHY ENGAGE IN MEDIATION? Litigation is…

Continue reading

Scroll to top